I Don't Get It
Chapter 2

The Neighbour Who Would Bang on the Ceiling

Somebody upstairs is playing music at one in the morning. Not loud enough to be an obvious disturbance. Just loud enough that you're awake. And you're clearly going to stay awake. You’re doing the arithmetic on how many hours you have left before the alarm goes off. It is a countdown that you can’t stop in your head.

Here's the part I don't get. That same person, if the music were coming down at them instead of down from them, would be on the stairs in about four minutes. Furious, entirely certain they were in the right. And they would be in the right. That's what makes it so strange. They already know the rule. They can recite it perfectly. They just can't hear it applying to themselves.

It isn't ignorance. Nobody has to be told that noise at one in the morning is a problem. Everyone has been on the receiving end of it at some point. The knowledge is already in there. It just doesn't seem to survive the trip from one direction to the other.

What I think happens is that when you're the one making the noise, you have all the context. You know it's a one-off, you know it's your birthday, you know you'll turn it down soon. Or you at least know how long it is going to go on for. You're inside your own reasons, and your reasons are always good. But the person lying awake downstairs doesn't get any of that. They just get the noise. They're not experiencing your intentions, they're experiencing your output. And we consistently judge ourselves on the first thing and everyone else on the second.

The test is actually very simple. Would you accept this if it were coming at you? Not just in principle; not on a good day when you are fresh and energetic, but on a day which has been hard; when you are tired, with an exhausted mind and when you know that you have to recover and get back to work the next day. Would you accept it then? If your answer is that you would be okay with it even at your worst, then I understand why you would expect others to be okay with it too. But if you wouldn’t want it done to you, there’s your answer.

The same shape shows up in places where nobody's just losing sleep. It's the two minutes saved, the trip not made, the small convenience bought with somebody else's risk — always small enough to justify from the inside, always someone else absorbing it.

And the thing is, none of this is a difficult moral position. It's not a philosophy. It's the first thing anyone teaches a child, and every one of us can apply it flawlessly the moment we're the injured party; the moment it has affected us. Everyone sees it soon as it is happening to them. And then they do it themselves.

I don't get it.

3 responses
Amit Hasak

The Neighbor The human trait of being considerate to others was always a challenge. Nowadays in the self absorbed and isolated world we live in, even more so. Well written

Shraddha Nigavekar

Shifting Parameters: judging our Self on intentions and others on their output. Well put!

Srihari

In tamizh we say Naan Venum tu pannala As if that is going to somehow reduce the pain Semma

Read a chapter, or read an entire book. Share your thoughts in the comments section, if you like. Share a chapter, or share a book, if you would like someone else to read it.